Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회지)

The Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study on the Experts' Perception for Effective Application of Low Impact Development

저영향개발 기법의 효율적인 적용을 위한 전문가 인식 유형에 관한 연구

  • Lee, HyunJi (Korea Environment Institute) ;
  • Lee, Junga (Division of Environmental Science and Ecological Engineering, Korea University) ;
  • You, Soojin (Dept. of Environmental Science and Ecological Engineering, Graduate School, Korea University) ;
  • Chon, Jinhyung (Division of Environmental Science and Ecological Engineering, Korea University)
  • 이현지 (한국환경정책.평가연구원) ;
  • 이정아 (고려대학교 환경생태공학부) ;
  • 유수진 (고려대학교 대학원 환경생태공학과) ;
  • 전진형 (고려대학교 환경생태공학부)
  • Received : 2016.04.01
  • Accepted : 2016.06.23
  • Published : 2016.06.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

LID(Low-Impact Development) has received a great deal of attention in the field of urban water management. The spread of LID technologies as a natural drainage system has led to a rise in consideration of the applicability of policy in Korea. In this respect, the purpose of this study is to analyze experts' perception about utilization, applicability of policy, and improvements of LID by using Q-methodology. The sample included 31 experts who were government employees, landscape architects, researchers, and professors related to LID. All participants completed a 28-statement Q-sort task. Data was analyzed by using QUANL computer software. As a result of this study, four distinct experts' perceptions about LID are identified: Policy Enforcement Oriented Type, Expert Understanding Oriented Type, Manual Oriented Type, and Effectiveness Oriented Type. This study suggested appropriate directions related to LID technologies, and it is helpful to apply the domestic type's LID and increase the efficiency of LID in Korea. However, this study has a limit in which the viewpoint of the researcher intervenes: a complementary searcher is needed to verify the validity by type in policy decision-making.

전 세계적으로 도시내 물관리 정책 적용에 대한 관심이 증가하고 있다. 국내에서는 대상지의 자연적인 물순환 기능을 유지할 수 있는 저영향개발에 대한 관심이 증가하고 있으며, 이를 정책적으로 활용하려는 움직임을 보이고 있다. 이에 본 연구에서는 Q 방법론을 활용하여 저영향개발 기법의 이용 현황과 정책적 접근 방법, 개선사항 등에 대한 전문가적 견해의 인식 유형을 분석하고자 한다. 표본을 추출을 위한 전문가 심층 인터뷰는 31명의 LID와 관련된 공무원, 실무자, 연구원, 교수를 통해 이루어졌으며, 모든 응답자는 28개의 Q-sort 진술문에 응답하였다. 수집된 응답 결과는 QUANL 프로그램을 이용하여 분석하였다. 연구 결과, 도출된 유형은 해당 진술문의 성격에 따라 다음과 같이 4개로 구분되었다: 정책시행 중시형, 전문가 이해 중시형, 매뉴얼 중시형, 그리고 실효성 중시형. 본 연구에서는 유형별 특성 분석을 바탕으로 국내에 적합한 저영향개발 기법의 적용을 위한 정책적 발전 방향을 논의하였으며, 저영향개발 기법의 적용 확대 및 효율성 증대에 기여할 수 있을 것으로 기대한다. 그러나 본 연구의 방법론 특성상 정량적인 연구결과 해석 시 연구자의 관점이 개입된다는 점이 한계로 지적될 수 있으므로, 향후 정책 의사결정에 있어 유형별 타당성을 검증하기 위한 상호 보완적인 연구가 필요할 것이다.

Keywords

References

  1. Ahiablame, L. M., A. E. Bernard and I. Chaubey(2013) Effectiveness of low impact development practices in two urbanized watersheds: Retrofitting with rain barrel/cistern and porous pavement. Journal of Environmental Management 119(1): 151-161. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2013.01.019
  2. Baek, P. G. and H. S. Lee(2011) The meaning of 'Subjectivity' researches in HRD: Focusing on Q methodology. The Adult and Continuing Education of Korea 14(1): 1-37.
  3. Brown, S. R.(1980) Political Subjectivity: Applications of Methodology in Political Science. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
  4. Choi, J. S., K. H. Hyun, J. M. Lee, M. S. Kang and S. K. Jung(2012) Issues and improvements in extended application of LID technologies. Korea Water Resources Association 2012 Proceedings.
  5. Davies, B. B. and I. D. Hodge(2012) Shifting environmental perspectives in agriculture: Repeated Q analysis and the stability of preference structures. Ecological Economics 83: 51-57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.08.013
  6. Ewing, R. H. and R. Hodder(2014) Best development practices: A primer for smart growth. Smart Growth Network.
  7. Gil, B. O. and C. M. Kim(2010) Q methodology's theory and application: North Korean defectors' self reverential subjectivity and the direction for homogeneity's recovery between South and North. The Korea Association for Policy Analysis and Evaluation (2): 101-129.
  8. Gilroy, K. L. and R. H. McCuen(2009) Spatio-temporal effects of low impact development practices. Journal of Hydrology 367(3-4): 228-236. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2009.01.008
  9. Han, S. J.(2010) Emotional response of civil servants to new public management reform: An application of Q-methodology. The Korea Institute of Public Affairs of Seoul National University 48(3): 25-57.
  10. Hyun, K. H., J. G. Kim, E. Y. Lee, S. K. Kim, Y. W. Chu and J. E. Yoo(2012) Installation manual and monitoring of LID - Decentralized rainwater management facilities in Asan Tangjung. Korea Land & Housing Corporation. Research Report.
  11. Jang, T. K., J. J. Kim, T. D. Kim, D. H. Choi and J. H. Jeon(2011) Analysis with non-point reduction efficiency of tourism complex zone through LID. Korean Society on Water Environment. Spring Conference Paper. pp. 377-378.
  12. JDI(Jeonbuk Development Institute)(2010) A research on application plan of the city development area for water quality improvement in Saemangeum. Report of Jeonbuk Development Institute.
  13. Jung, G. H.(2000) A Q-methodological study on the types of environmental conservation discourses. Korea Environmental Policy and Administration Society 8(1): 93-111.
  14. Jung, S. K., K. W. Jeon, B. H. Jeon and C. D. Jang(2013) The suggestion of future drought reduction using rainfall storage techniques for rainwater control. Korean Review of Crisis & Emergency Management 9(2): 95-104.
  15. Kang, C. G., M. C. Maniquiz, Y. G. Son, H. J. Cho and L. H. Kim (2011) Development of small constructed wetland for urban and roadside areas. Journal of Korean Wetlands Society 13(2): 231-242.
  16. Kang, D. K.(2009) Low impact development. Journal of Korean Society of Civil Engineers 57(7): 95-100.
  17. Kang, M. J., S. J. Lee, B. I. Kim and D. S. Shin(2011) Present status and future tasks in implementing low impact development. Journal of Korean Society on Water Environment Conference Paper. pp. 339-340.
  18. KEI(Korea Environment Institute)(2010) Application and effects of low impact development in urban regeneration of waterfront areas. Research Report to KEI.
  19. Kim, K. Y., D. K. Cho and I. K. Song(2013) How to promote smart TV industry in Korea: Based on scientific tool for qualitative methodology. PACIS 2013 Proceeding Paper. pp.67.
  20. Kim, D. H. and H. S. Choi(2013) The planning process and simulation for low impact development(LID) in waterfront area. A Study on Environmental Policy 12(1): 37-58. https://doi.org/10.17330/joep.12.1.201303.37
  21. Kim, D. H., S. H. Choi, H. J. Kim and W. J. Shin(2013) An analysis on the categories of livable village by Q-methode? What village do people wish to live in?. Journal of Korea Planners Association 48(5): 51-66.
  22. Kim, G. H., Y. C. Lee and E. Y. Lee(2012) The subjective perception types of citizen's participation in neighbourhood-making project. Journal of Korea Design Forum 35: 27-38.
  23. Kim, H. K.(2008) Q Methodology: Philosophy of Science, Theory, Analysis and Application. Seoul: Communication Books.
  24. Kim, H. S. and U. M. Won(2000) Q Methodology. Seoul: Kyoyook Gwahak Sa.
  25. Kim, J. H.(2010) Prospects and limits on the grounded theory as an approach of case study in the public administration. Proceedings of the Symposium Presentation of Korean Society and Public Administration pp. 753-765.
  26. Kim, J. J., T. D. Kim, D. C. Choi and J. H. Jeon(2011) Design of structural BMPs for low impact development(LID) application and modelling its effect on reduction of runoff and nonpoint source pollution: Application of LIDMOD2. Journal of Korean Society on Water Quality 27(5): 580-586.
  27. Kim, M. N.(2013) LID Evaluation of the Stormwater Management Planning for LID Adoption -Case Studies of Apartment Complex in Jeonju City, South Korea-. Master Degree Thesis, Chonbuk National University. Jeonbuk, Korea.
  28. Kim, R. H.(2013) The policy and application method for healthy water circulation city's creation. Landscape Architecture Korea 2013(8): 42-47.
  29. Kim, S. E.(2010) Q methodology's theory and philosophy. Korea Society and Public Administration 20(4): 1-25.
  30. Kim, W. H.(2013) A proposal for effective introduction of internal water circulation plan. Landscape Architecture Korea 2013(8): 54-61.
  31. Kim, Y. H.(2006) The issues and implications of epistemological research in educational psychology. Liberal and Social Science Research 7: 89-110.
  32. KSSSS(Korean Society for the Scientific Study of Subjectivity)(2014) Application and Case of Q method. Seoul: Prunsasang.
  33. Lee, J. M., K. H. Hyun, Y. S. Lee, J. G. Kim, Y. B. Park and J. S. Choi(2011) Analysis of water cycle effect by plan of LID-decentralized rainwater management using SWMM-LID model in a low-carbon green village. LHI Journal of Korea Land & Housing Corporation 2(4): 503-507. https://doi.org/10.5804/LHIJ.2011.2.4.503
  34. Lee, Y. G.(2013) The characteristic and the case of LID application for the creation of sustainable water environment. Gyeongnam Development Institute (127): 91-106.
  35. Lim, Y. K.(2011) A Study of LID Technologies for Friendly Environmental Urban Development. Docotr's Degree Thesis, Busan University. Busan, Korea.
  36. MOE(Ministry of Environment)(2009) The Management Plan of Natural Source of Pollution using LID Technique.
  37. MOE(Ministry of Environment)(2013) The Guideline on the LID Technique Element for Creation of Healthy Water Circulation System.
  38. Park, H. J. and M. Y. Han(2011) Water cycle system in Suwon city by rainwater management. Journal of Korean Society on Water Environment. Conference Paper. pp. 189-190.
  39. Park, H. J., Y. G. Yoo, J. G. Kim, Y. K. Park, H. T. Yoon and K. J. Lim(2008) Analysis of runoff reduction with LID adoption using the SWMM. Korean Society on Water Environment 24(6): 806-816.
  40. Park, H. S., S. Lee, K. H. Park and E. G. Chang(2010) Conflict management in spatial development projects: Exploring people's perception and finding policy application. Anyang: Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements.
  41. Prince George's County, Maryland Department of Environmental Resources (PGDER)(1999) Low-Impact Development Design Strategies: An Integrated Design Approach. Department of Environmental Resources, Programs and Planning Division, Prince George's County: Maryland.
  42. Seoul Metropolitan City(2013) Seoul, 'The Creation of Healthy Water Circulation City' Comprehensive Plan Announcement. A News Release of Seoul Metropolitan City.
  43. Watts S. and P. Stenner (2012) Doing Q Methodology: Theory, Method and Interpretation. Los Angeles: Sage.
  44. Yang H. E. and Y. Son(2013) The inflow of the creative-class and forming of cultural landscape on the Kyunglidan-Gil. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 41(6): 158-170. https://doi.org/10.9715/KILA.2013.41.6.158
  45. http://yonhappnews.co.kr